Is Your Neighbor Undercutting your Listing Price? (What to do when someone lists for less)

Is Your Neighbor Undercutting your Listing Price? (What to do when someone lists for less)

You’ve prepped your home, set a thoughtful price, and listed it—then a “For Sale” sign appears nearby with a lower price. It’s unsettling, but a cheaper listing doesn’t mean your home is overpriced. Here’s how to assess the situation and protect your home’s value.


Why Would a Neighbor List for Less?

Real estate pricing can be personal or strategic. Common reasons include:

  1. Motivated Seller
    Life events like divorce, foreclosure, or relocation may push sellers to price low for a quick sale.
  2. Not Truly Comparable
    Similar-looking homes may differ in condition, upgrades, or layout. An outdated kitchen or old HVAC can justify a lower price.
  3. Pricing Tactic
    Some sellers price low to spark a bidding war, though this risks anchoring buyer expectations downward.
  4. Inexperienced Agent
    Poor pricing advice from an inexperienced agent can lead to an underpriced listing.

Why You Shouldn’t Slash Your Price

Avoid knee-jerk price cuts—they can backfire. Instead, consider:

  1. Your Home’s Unique Value
    Upgrades, better location, or superior finishes add measurable worth. A good agent can highlight these differences.
  2. Buyers Seek Value, Not Just Price
    A well-staged home with strong marketing sells faster than a cheap, poorly presented one.
  3. Low Prices Can Raise Doubts
    Underpricing may signal issues, slowing sales or dragging down nearby listings.

Make Your Home Stand Out

Focus on what sets your home apart:

  • Professional Marketing
    Use high-quality photos, video tours, or 3D walkthroughs to showcase your home’s appeal.
  • Highlight Features
    Emphasize pools, upgraded kitchens, or energy-efficient systems to justify your price.
  • Lifestyle Appeal
    Market your home’s benefits: great for entertaining, near top schools, or low-maintenance.
  • Staging
    A clean, decluttered home adds perceived value, often outweighing a small price gap.

When to Rethink Your Price

Listen to the market for signs to adjust:

  1. No Showings in 7–14 Days
    Few or no showings suggest your price isn’t competitive.
  2. Negative Feedback
    Comments like “it feels overpriced” are actionable data.
  3. Outlier Status
    If similar homes sell while yours sits, reassess pricing.
  4. Market Shifts
    Rising rates or inventory changes may require a pivot. Stay updated with your agent.

In Closing: Stay Strategic

A neighbor’s low price doesn’t define your home’s value. Work with me as your agent to highlight strengths, market smartly, and price confidently. Even if a price improvement appears necessary, we can often increase rate buydowns, lowering the buyers monthly cost far more, while supporting your sales price. The goal isn’t just a fast sale—it’s a smart one. Question? Give Kevin Williams a call - simply grab your phone and ask Siri or Google: "Who is the Realtor in the Fedora?" and they'll connect us!

Let’s Find Your Perfect Home Together

Have questions about buying, selling, or investing in real estate? Get expert guidance tailored to your needs. Reach out today and take the first step toward your next move!